Rustic Bakes

Small-batch breads, rolls, pastries, bars, cookies, and seaonal barn favorites all baked to order. Build you order below and submit once you’re ready. No payment is taken here; we’ll confirm availability and send your invoice.

Stuffed Cookies

Biscoff Cookies Crunch

A classic cookie stuffed with Biscoff Cookie Butter and a Biscoff cookie

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Cookie Monster

Chocolate chip cookie stuffed with a Chips Ahoy and an Oreo for the ultimate Cookie Monster bite

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Double Trouble

A chocolate chip cookie stuffed with homemade brownies

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Caramel Snicker

A snickerdoodle cookie stuffed with caramel and rolled in cinnamon sugar

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Triple Chocolate

A chocolate, chocolate chip cookie stuffed with nutella

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Overload

A classic cookie stuffed with a mini-Cinnamon roll and topped icing drizzle and Cinnamon sugar

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Cereal Killer

A classic cookie stuffed with Fruity Pebbles and Krispie bars and topped with more Fruity Pebbles

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Oreo Cake Batter

A funfetti cake batter cookie stuffed and topped Oreos

$6.00 each

Quantity:

PB Bomb

A chocolate, chocolate chip cookie stuffed with peanut butter

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Monster Cookie

Monster cookie loaded with oats, M&Ms, peanuts, and butterscotch chips, stuffed with a rich, creamy peanut butter

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Espresso Fudge

A rich espresso-infused cookie packed with decadent fudge

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Reese's

A peanut butter chocolate chip cookie stuffed with a full Reese's cup

$6.00 each

Quantity:

Sourdough

Plain Loaf

A classic naturally fermented sourdough with a soft and tangy interior

$10.00 each

Quantity:

Jalapeno Bacon Cheddar

Savory sourdough loaded with real melted smoky bacon, and a hint of jalapeno heat

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Maple Bacon

A sweet-savory sourdough loaf featuring real maple flavor and crispy bacon throughout

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Sugar

Soft, pillowy sweet sourdough with cinnamon and sugar for a lightly sweet, cozy loaf

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Double Chocolate

Rich cocoa sourdough studded with chocolate chips for a dessert-style twist on a classic loaf

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Garlic, Cheddar, & Herb

Flavor-packed sourdough with garlic, melted cheddar, and a blend of savory herbs

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Coffee Cake

A moist cinnamon coffee cake made with sourdough discard and finished with a buttery crumb topping - 8"x4" loaf

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies made with sourdough discard for extra depth and flavor - 1 dozen

$20.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Plain

0.5 LB

$4.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Jalapeno Bacon Cheddar

0.5 LB

$5.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Maple Bacon

0.5 LB

$5.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Cinnamon Sugar

0.5 LB

$5.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Double Chocolate

0.5 LB

$5.00 each

Quantity:

Mini Garlic, Cheddar, & Herb

0.5 LB

$5.00 each

Quantity:

Cupcakes

Custom Dozen

Put your flavor, color, and design requests in the "Special Requests or Notes" section of your cart.

$35.00 each

Quantity:

Gender Reveal

Put your flavor and color requests in the "Special Requests or Notes" section of your cart - 1 dozen

$32.00 each

Quantity:

Lemon Blueberry

Lemon cupcakes filled with house-made lemon curd and topped with blueberry compote buttercream - 1 dozen

$35.00 each

Quantity:

Cakesicles (dozen)

Your choice of flavor, color, and designs! Put details in the comment section of the order request or send me an email.

$45.00 each

Quantity:

Cookie Decorating Kits

50s Diner

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Vintage Vegas

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Murder Mystery

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Goofy Grub

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Emotional Damage

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Girl Dinner

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Hotdog Party

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Cartoon Desserts

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Barnyard

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instruction

$30.00 each

Quantity:

80s Retro

This cookie decorating set includes 4 cookies, all coordinating icing colors, and step-by-step video decorating instructions

$30.00 each

Quantity:

Amy’s Freshly Milled Bread

FMB Handout Why & All Combined

Made with freshly milled whole grains for richer flavor, better texture, and more natural nutrients than traditional flour. Milling fresh preserves the wheat berry’s natural oils and nutrients, creating a hearty, wholesome loaf with incredible flavor and freshness in every bite. Email Amy with any questions at

Plain Loaf

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Rasin

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Onion Herb

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Swirl

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Fresh Apple

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Oats & Honey

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Orange Cranberry

1 LB

$12.00 each

Quantity:

12" Pizza Dough

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Plain Loaf

1.5 LB

$15.00 each

Quantity:

Cinnamon Rasin

1.5 LB

$15.00 each

Quantity:

Dark Molasess Oatmeal

1.5 LB

$15.00 each

Quantity:

Banana Bread

Banana Bread can be made with or without chocolate chips

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Date Quick Bread

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Apple Pie Quick Bread

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Pineapple Zucchini Quick Bread

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Honey Pumpkin Quick Bread

$12.00 each

Quantity:

Rustic Bakes Order Request Form

Order stuffed cookies and sourdough products

Contact Information

Name(Required)

Email(Required)

Phone Number(Required)

Preferred Contact Method(Required)

Text

Call

Items and quantities you selected:

Total$0.00

Order Details

Desired Pickup Date(Required)

Special Requests or Notes

Policies Acknowledgement(Required)

I acknowledge and agree to the policies

All Rustic Bakes items are made to order and require a minimum notice time, which may vary based on volume and availability. Orders are not confirmed until I review your request, verify the pickup date, and send an invoice. Because everything is baked fresh for your specific order, cancellations made less than 48 hours before pickup may still be charged in full. All products are prepared in a shared kitchen where common allergens are present, and while care is taken, cross-contamination may occur. Payment is required before or at pickup to finalize your order.

Rustic Bakes

Stuffed Cookies

Sourdough

Cupcakes

Cookie Decorating Kits

Amy’s Freshly Milled Bread

Rustic Bakes Order Request Form

Contact Information

Order Details

Quick Links

Contact Info

Cart Summary